Jersey City
A fixer-upper, a bidding war, and the offer that gave the seller certainty.
44 Sherman Ave, Jersey City. Closed March 2025.
- List price
- $240,000
- Sale price
- $245,000
- Closed
- March 2025
- Terms
- Inspection and appraisal waived

The story
In January the market was quiet, but I could feel spring coming. This unit at 44 Sherman had been sitting a little while, it was a total fixer-upper, and it was priced to move. My buyer and I knew that combination would not last. Once the spring buyers woke up, this was going to be a real deal, and we wanted to be in front of it.
We were not the only ones who saw it. It turned into a bidding war. Here is where my time on the listing side changes how I play offense. I know exactly how a listing agent reads offers and how they talk through them with their sellers. Price matters, but a seller is really buying one thing, and that thing is certainty. They do not want a deal that falls apart three weeks in.
So that is what we sold them. We came in slightly above asking at $245,000 on a $240,000 list, and then we made the rest of the offer airtight. I had my buyer's lender call the listing agent directly so they heard the strength of the financing straight from the source. We waived inspection and appraisal where it made sense for my client, and we made it clear this would be a clean, easy transaction from contract to close. The whole team moved as one unit.
We won, not because we were the highest number on the page, but because we were the surest thing in the room. The proof came fast. A smaller unit down the hall, one that needed the same renovations ours did, later sold for more than we paid even though our unit was larger. My buyer saw the value the day they signed. That is the job of a buyer's agent in a competitive market. You remove the seller's doubt, and you get your client the home.
Work with Dominic Rosato